Engine Ice VS Peak Sierra and Supercool VS Water Wetter

mudrunner88

Webmaster
Administrator
Joined
Jan 27, 2010
Messages
1,736
Reaction score
28
Location
South Carolina
So I had to drain the Engine Ice out of my dirtbike. P.O. had used it for what ever reason...I was doing maintenance and had to pull the water pump so I drained it all.

Tonight I went and read about all this to find out why it cost so much.

My conclusion...Engine Ice is nothing more than Propylene Glycol coolant (Specifically Peak Sierra)
Want proof? Read the MSDS!

http://www.engineice.com/msds_engineice.pdf

http://images.peakauto.com/Sierra Concentrate Antifreeze & Coolant Rev 052013.pdf

Then I went on to read the MSDS for Redline Water Wetter and Supercool.

Guess what...Supercool is just overprice De-Ionized water with a jug of water wetter thrown in it! Spend a few bucks on water wetter and buy some de-ionized water from the druge store for a buck or two.

Or just buy Peak Sierra coolant and call it a day...If you want insurance add the 7 dollar bottle of water wetter to Peak Sierra!
 
But . . . but . . . this can't be! My engine runs cooler with Engine Ice . . . I can tell . . . it just does. :laughing7:
 
:hello: I went to get antifreeze at Or'alleys Auto parts just for what reason I don't know I asked them what brand is for motorcycles. I have always used Peak in all my motorized machines. They did not know so they called the shop across the street & they said no car antifreeze works in motorcycles. I was told as long as it does not have silicone & phosphates in it it is OK for bikes. Then again I was told that the water pumps in are old ZLs is not affected by those chemicals. My friend Ron who has worked as a motorcycle tech since the 60s has always told me that the Engine ice & such is hog wash.
 
:hello: I was saying which chemicals that would harm your bikes coolant system. What is Sierra Peak. Never seen it in FL. All's I seen was PEAK.
 
Do you mean Ethylene Glycol?

That is what is recommended in the service manual, 50/50 Distilled water & Ethylene Glycol.

This isn't really ZL specific. I'm aware of the Ethylene Glycol, it is the main ingredient in 95% of the anti-freeze on the market.

The Propylene Glycol is the main ingredient in the ones they say are 'Safe and Environment Friendly'.

Other members have used 'Engine Ice' in their bikes and dirtbikes and it is quite expensive for 1/2 gallon. I just wanted to point out to people that it is nothing special. Same thing as the environmentally safe anti-freezes on the market...Prestone Low Tox is another version besides Peak Sierra.

Just don't want my brothers wasting money on something that 'makes it run cooler' (as Engine Ice says).
:hello: I was saying which chemicals that would harm your bikes coolant system. What is Sierra Peak. Never seen it in FL. All's I seen was PEAK.
http://prestone.com/products/antifreeze_coolant/product_list?select_region=1 Scoll down to see Prestone Low Tox

http://www.peakauto.com/products/antifreeze-coolants/automotive/sierra/ This is the Sierra link

http://www.engineice.com/ Engine ice link

Propylene Gylcol is safe for Aluminum engines.
 
Thanks, I appreciate that. I have to admit that I have been using Engine Ice in my 900 for 6 years but that was because Dale Walker
said it was the way to go & Mark said that Dale was the man when it came to the old ZL's.

Have a friend who races classic midget cars and he has been using Water Wetter forever, so I was thinking of trying that in the future, or not.
 
I'm not saying don't use it, just showing ya all how to save damn near 50% :headbang:
You basically get a gallon of Propylene Glycol for the same price as 1/2 gallon of the other.

I used supercool in my ZRX1200 setup.
But again it was $22-$23 for 1/2 gallon.

All you have to do is get a $11.00 bottle of Redline water wetter and then mix it with some distilled water from your friendly drug store.

I just ordered silicone hoses for my dirtbike...When I swap them I plan to try Propylene Glycol with Water Wetter.


If your local auto store doesn't know what Propylene Glycol is, tell them you are a hippy and want the stuff that is safe for the environment...Then check the label on the back.
 
Engine Ice or what ever brand makes the same stuff dosnt matter to me The engine is built to run at a set temp and that is fixed by the thermostat

What does matter to me is that what ever you use is somewhat transparent as engine Ice is as it has proven to me time and again that with aluminum engines anything dark in color seems to leave pitting in the system and can accumulate a gunky type of build up for some reason. I didn't switch to Engine Ice for a cooler running engine but rather to keep the internals clean. The stock antifreeze that came in my truck in 2003 was very similar in its semi transparency to engine ice but had a rather orange tint to it but it has accumulated gunk over the years. So now I will only use a coolant that is the same color as engine ice and really don't care who makes it as long as the ingrediants are the same as engine ice with nothing but the blue color being the final product.

So what color is this other stuff as it has been years since I compared different types of antifreeze?

Also the smaller bottle of engine Ice is very easy to carry home on the bike even when I don't have a bag on the bike as opposed to the gal jugs of other stuff.
 
It's lite green in color Paul with a boiling point a couple degrees higher and a few $ less than E.I. Both good at protecting aluminum internals.http://www.maximausa.com/shopping/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=3 http://www.amazon.com/Maxima-82964-Coolanol-Performance-Coolant/dp/B0012TROMU Maybe even less $ shopping around. I have had zero issues with any O-rings/seals or temp problems in the summer ever since I've been using it which has been for many years. struts and web coil cleaner 020.JPG This stuff is also a good product for the radiator, safe, cheap and get's grime out from in between the tiny fins like crazy.
 
Hey that fin cleaning stuff looks cool. Usually I use an engine degreaser that is safe for aluminum and let it sit...Then spray with hose.

So as far as Coolanol goes, it seems just a fancy name for Prestone or any other general Anti-Freeze. Nothing special about it from what I can see.
Here is their MSDS: http://www.maxima.co.jp/images/msds/misc/Coolanol.pdf
and they state MonoEthylene Glycol is the main ingredient.

So I did a little reading and MonoEthylene Glycol is just a synonym for Ethylene Glycol. Now that we know this, here is Prestones MSDS: https://www.lakeland.edu/PDFs/MSDS/18/Antifreeze (All Brands).pdf

So to the untrained eye they seem like a different product because of the chemical name. But look at the second column where it says "CAS#" (Chemical Abstract Service Number).

OH NO, IT CAN'T BE! The numbers are the SAME!!! It is the same chemical.
Actually in the Prestone they use a stronger percentage of Glycol vs. any water that gets added to dilute it.


I'm sure they act a little different because of the percentages but otherwise they seem to be the same.

This is turning out to be quite interesting.
 
Back
Top